This was selected from my ever growing, never shrinking "to read" pile on the grounds that Kateri also thought she should read it too. So here we are with the March reading challenge:
I Capture the Castle- Dodie Smith.
I knew nothing of this book expect that it appears on several "must read" lists. This is always a worry, books with brilliant reputations and the accolade of being a "must read" often disappoint so I was glad to have no further knowledge to set me up false expectations. In saying that, had it not been on these lists I would not have picked it up in a charity shop.
The book immediately appealed as I realised it was to be told in the form of a journal- I do like a book that makes me feel like I'm peering directly into people's minds and thoughts or where I oughtn't to be. What that says about me I wouldn't like to speculate. The story was simple enough to discern early on with the good family turned to poverty beginning it seemed impossible that this wouldn't be a rags to riches tale. There were typical characters and developments- wealthy eligible bachelors, improbable inheritances, implausible meetings and the love story.
"I write this sitting in the kitchen sink. That is, my feet are in it, the rest of me is on the draining board"
I feel I make it sound predictable and run of the mill! It was anything but, I found the book engaging, I wanted to find out how the twists and turns of fate would take us to the end of the tale. I loved the setting; who wouldn't love to live in a run down, practically uninhabitable castle with towers and moat. It just sounds beyond idyllic and like every dream I ever had as a romantic teenager. In fact, given half a chance I would still move to a castle.

{Eilean Donan Castle, July 2010}
The voice of Cassandra throughout her journal is one of the high points with her being aware of her naivety (in fact, "consciously naive") and her thoughts and understanding of things beyond her small world, beyond that of her sister or brother- even than her father and step mother. If I had read this book at 15 I would have wanted to be just like her. The other characters struggle a bit with depth in places- perhaps because there are so many of them for such a short book- but not so much as to ruin the enjoyment of the book.
The down side is the ending, it neither ties everything up nicely or leaves you wanting more with the thought that life continues for the characters. It appeared just to fizzle out and stop, very dis-satisfying indeed. I just didn't feel I had enough to create my own future for the characters or for the future to have been defined for them.

